[Azzo]

why would you add charges to tubs, makes no sense the problem is having rare dye tubs you can actually choose from rewards not from getting it rarely from clicking.

I disagree, the issue isn't the colours people are getting, more that people have access to so many.

With skill reward tubs, you only get to gm tailoring once, maybe some really dedicated people will do it twice, and you may have one or two people do it 3 times but each person really only gets a single colour. The benefit of this is it encourages people trading cloth, clothes and other dyeables of the colour they own.

With rare tubs purchasable as they are now, while the colour is random they're accessible enough that people can have 20+ tubs, habibi is even claiming some guilds have 100+. No economy for colored cloth etc. at that point.

Back to the topic at hand though, instead of making the tubs rarer, or disposable with a limited number of charges, maybe make it so they can only be used once (or some small number) a day.