[Eru]

Why not just make it so that any shield type can be picked? Not much point in limiting it to 1 in my opinion.
Order and chaos shields should of course still be reserved for the factions.

Or just make it like old days where you could only pick from order/chaos but there were no restrictions as to what you could pick.

The reasoning I have is that to have an active PVP community, we need either people who are willing to PK and go red, or a larger number of chaos/order guilds to have faction fighting.

If we make all the coolest stuff for the neutral guilds, then there's no reason to go order/chaos and it hurts the PVP.

The reason I want to change the neutral shield is that since it is a fame reward, it does make sense to have something better than a crappy metal shield.

Also, note that most people are either neutral guilded or un-guilded, so a vote thread like this may be biased since more people will vote in favor of what gives more advantages to neutral guilds.

We really should come up with some cool incentive for PVPing...