[Ramza]

I think the luck in melee pvp likely has to do with the weapons that are typically used. Seems like the more damage potential the weapon has, the bigger range of damage it has. A halbred/bardich can do a ton of damage, but it can do very little. 1h weapons seem more consistent, but I haven't tested this extensively, so I could be wrong there. Bandages seem a bit random, but that's what makes it interesting in my opinion. You never know what you will have to do in the next couple seconds. It forces you to think on your feet.

That being said, I suppose there isn't much variation in spells. A heal does a set amount, same with attacks as far as I can tell. Not sure why there is variance in melee and not spells, but I assume there is a logical reason.