11-07-2011, 10:49 AM
I looked at the server status and I noticed a few people in the guild "Elven Elf." I was a little confused about the guild name so I came here and found this thread.
What was your reasoning for your choice of guild name? Redundant?
I'm also a little confused about your player name. It doesn't strike me as Elvish. After a quick Google search I discovered that "Devilman" is the name given to the title character in a Japanese manga series. The name obviously is derived from the two words "Devil" and "Man." The character is possessed by a demon.
Your story speaks of your guild as being a guild of do-gooders. You supposedly possess the good nature of typical elves found in lore. Why would you want to kill daemons while you're an elf, but at the same time have a name that implies you're part devil & man?
"If a player chooses to play the role of a murderous villain who lives his life to slaughter everyone he meets, it would not make sense for him to be helping any other person. Likewise, if someone was to play the role of a holy man who lives for the good of the people, this person cannot kill for any reason."
I feel that player names should also apply. It does not make sense for an Elf to have a name which includes the word "devil" or "man." Although, "Devilman" may directly translate to "anointed one" in Elvish.
I'm all for role play, but I recall it being a bit more strict on IN1. My argument isn't completely unfounded. I suspect this will be taken as an attack and this post will eventually be removed. Meh :
hrugs::
What was your reasoning for your choice of guild name? Redundant?
I'm also a little confused about your player name. It doesn't strike me as Elvish. After a quick Google search I discovered that "Devilman" is the name given to the title character in a Japanese manga series. The name obviously is derived from the two words "Devil" and "Man." The character is possessed by a demon.
Your story speaks of your guild as being a guild of do-gooders. You supposedly possess the good nature of typical elves found in lore. Why would you want to kill daemons while you're an elf, but at the same time have a name that implies you're part devil & man?
"If a player chooses to play the role of a murderous villain who lives his life to slaughter everyone he meets, it would not make sense for him to be helping any other person. Likewise, if someone was to play the role of a holy man who lives for the good of the people, this person cannot kill for any reason."
I feel that player names should also apply. It does not make sense for an Elf to have a name which includes the word "devil" or "man." Although, "Devilman" may directly translate to "anointed one" in Elvish.
I'm all for role play, but I recall it being a bit more strict on IN1. My argument isn't completely unfounded. I suspect this will be taken as an attack and this post will eventually be removed. Meh :
hrugs::